Best New EL84

Tube-specific discussions

Moderators: CurtissRobin, colossal, zaphod_phil

User avatar
zaphod_phil
Builder, Admin
Builder, Admin
Posts: 15208
Joined: Wed 03/19/03 2:00 am
Location: YYZ

Post by zaphod_phil »

pato wrote:I have the exact same amp + same tubes (JJ EL84s) and had the exact same experience. I don't know if they were too gainy or what, but the sound when the amp was cranked was much too grainy and brittle for my liking. Put the 6v6s in and it was much better.
drake wrote:I do urge you to try a pair of the new EH EL84´s; they´re different to the normal Sovteks, and sound even better than old Tesla roundplate/hexplates that I´ve had in the past, and last much longer; get a hot set and you may be in for a surprise; more bass and more crunchy mids, and the highs aren´t so "bitey" anymore :wink: and the sustain...... :lol: 8)
So Pato, maybe you need to try the EH EL84s to get the kind of tone you like from EL84s.
pato wrote:However, I thought that this could also have been contributed to the way the amp is set up... if you solder in the proper resistor for the EL84s, you can't just swap them out for 6v6s, but if you use the proper resistor for the 6v6s, you CAN swap them out for EL84s... but if you do the EL84s will be biased cold I THINK.
Yes, that's right, and it probably won't sound too good. So if you have two sets of power tube sockets, you need to put a different cathode resistor and cap on each. But you really also need a different resistor in the phase invertor for each type of tube - ie 22k or 47k.
0 x
Nature abhors a clean tube amp

leslie
Transformer Guy
Posts: 1082
Joined: Sun 03/12/06 2:00 am
Location: Dalmatia
Contact:

Post by leslie »

grndluxe wrote:i'm a little late on this topic, but just to add my 2 cents about EL84s.
i had a pair of JJs in a dockery TMB and thought they were a bit harsh at the time. i sold them on ebay and bought a pair of NOS General Rohrens. the JJs were much better. the Generals were very STERILE. no 'personality' at all.
general rohre are actually russian tubes which have nothing in common with german tubes of yesteryear( rohre = tube).
Simillar story with Zaerix tubes on ebay.
If you need good comparison with JJ try Tungsram or GE (you can still get them at good price NOS)

Not connected but general:
Also please notice that military tubes sometimes can sound sterile but have prolonged lifetime and whitstand higher plates voltages.

Regards
0 x

User avatar
supah
Occasional poster
Occasional poster
Posts: 111
Joined: Fri 01/11/08 2:00 am
Location: Upper east side baby!!
Contact:

Post by supah »

drake/phil -

by EH do you mean Electro-Harmonix?

phil -

so before start playing with ELs I should definitely put together an amp specifically for them... biased correctly and whatnot.
0 x
life is too short for bad tone.

drake
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 44
Joined: Mon 04/24/06 2:00 am

Post by drake »

supah wrote:drake/phil -

by EH do you mean Electro-Harmonix?
Yes, Electro Harmonix.

Got some old Russian 6P14P´s from the late 70´s recently; they seem very robust, you can rap yer knuckles on the glass, and nothing rattles!

Not sure how they´ll sound, I´ve read elsewhere that they take time to burn in... I´ll try ´em next tube-change.

The EL84EH´s do last a long time though, and sound GREAT!

Happy New Year :D
drake
0 x

rjgtr
Builder, Admin
Builder, Admin
Posts: 6668
Joined: Wed 11/24/04 2:00 am
Location: Jax, FL
Contact:

Post by rjgtr »

supah wrote: phil -

so before start playing with ELs I should definitely put together an amp specifically for them... biased correctly and whatnot.
You can make a new amp (an 18watt Lite IIb is a perfect start) or as phil says modify your existing amp to switch between the two types of tubes.

If the amp has both 8 and 9 pin sockets installed for the power tubes, you can share everything except for the cathode resistor/cap. You would have a different value for each type. Then you should also switch between a 47k and 22k on the PI. You can do this by having the 47k as your soldered in value and then paralleling in another 47k with a swtich (two 47k in parallel equals 23.5k - close enough).
0 x

Post Reply