5E3 and 18 watt classic: anyone has both?
Moderators: CurtissRobin, colossal, zaphod_phil, Daviedawg, Graydon
- Bieworm
- Verbose Moderator
- Posts: 2287
- Joined: Mon 02/10/20 8:24 am
- Location: Belgium
5E3 and 18 watt classic: anyone has both?
how would you compare the volume?
Which one is noisier?
Difference in beef?
Thx, BW
Which one is noisier?
Difference in beef?
Thx, BW
0 x
"THIS should be played at high volume..preferably in a residential area"
-
- Superior Amp Tech
- Posts: 748
- Joined: Fri 01/08/10 2:00 am
- Location: Scotland
Re: 5E3 and 18 watt classic: anyone has both?
My hand is up. I have both. They are both equally loud for home use. Very hard to say one is louder than the other. My 5E3 has never been out of the house. VVR works great on the 18 watt but not great on the 5E3 which looses tone very early. So I only play the Fender when I am home alone with the windows shut when it can be very rewarding.
The cab for the fender has a yellow frame G12/50 which does not help quiet things down.
The Scout has a single 10" Elac alnico which takes the normal circuit to a useable level. Still loud but not unbearable in a small room. So speaker choice for expected use is more than just for tone.
Dd
Edit. Sorry I addressed only loudness there. They do different jobs as it were. Maybe I would describe it in AC/DC terms as 18 watt for Angus and 5E3 for Malcolm. The 18 watt is brighter. The 5E3 has beast mode.
The cab for the fender has a yellow frame G12/50 which does not help quiet things down.
The Scout has a single 10" Elac alnico which takes the normal circuit to a useable level. Still loud but not unbearable in a small room. So speaker choice for expected use is more than just for tone.
Dd
Edit. Sorry I addressed only loudness there. They do different jobs as it were. Maybe I would describe it in AC/DC terms as 18 watt for Angus and 5E3 for Malcolm. The 18 watt is brighter. The 5E3 has beast mode.
2 x
-
- Frequent poster
- Posts: 914
- Joined: Mon 12/10/07 2:00 am
- Location: Melb, Aust
- Contact:
Re: 5E3 and 18 watt classic: anyone has both?
I've got an 18 Watt and borrowed a 5E3 at one point for a while.
As DD said the volume is similar. Both are quite gainy and get dirty quick. But the tone and quality of the distortion is completely different as can be heard in demo clips of each.
As DD said the volume is similar. Both are quite gainy and get dirty quick. But the tone and quality of the distortion is completely different as can be heard in demo clips of each.
1 x
- zaphod_phil
- Builder, Admin
- Posts: 15208
- Joined: Wed 03/19/03 2:00 am
- Location: YYZ
Re: 5E3 and 18 watt classic: anyone has both?
To me, a 5E3 has a much more ragged breakup than a Marshall 18W. I've read the famous "Paul C" mod fixes that issue. I've heard clips of the 5D3 and like it's smoothness compared to the 5E3. So for a new build of a tweed, I think I'd go for a 5D3.
0 x
Nature abhors a clean tube amp
-
- Unrated
- Posts: 8
- Joined: Sat 04/18/20 10:53 am
Re: 5E3 and 18 watt classic: anyone has both?
My 18 watt is still a pile of parts, but I can comment on the 5E3. When I built mine, I didn't have a 5Y3 rectifier, so I subbed a GZ34. I also added a switched NFB circuit, and since I had a tap on the PT, I added a switched "fixed"/cathode bias. My intent was to firm up the little amp in the "fixed" and NFB setting for more clean headroom. I achieved my goal, but didn't get the easy breakup in cathode bias until higher volume levels! I plan to install a 5Y3 and re-bias to see if I get the breakup the 5E3 is known for.
My 18 watt build is the TMB design, so it too may not be the "traditional" sound!
My 18 watt build is the TMB design, so it too may not be the "traditional" sound!
1 x
- zaphod_phil
- Builder, Admin
- Posts: 15208
- Joined: Wed 03/19/03 2:00 am
- Location: YYZ
Re: 5E3 and 18 watt classic: anyone has both?
Did you measure the difference in B+ voltage between the 5Y3 And GZ34. I expect it will have been higher, with the GZ34/5AR4, leading to later breakup. Why did you decide to use octal rectifiers, instead of the standard EZ81?
I feel sorry you chose to use NFB, as that deadens the amp's chime and harmonic richness.
An 18W TMB has the real deal 18W vibe, as long use you don't go spoiling it with stuff like NFB and fixed bias.
I feel sorry you chose to use NFB, as that deadens the amp's chime and harmonic richness.
An 18W TMB has the real deal 18W vibe, as long use you don't go spoiling it with stuff like NFB and fixed bias.
0 x
Nature abhors a clean tube amp
- Bieworm
- Verbose Moderator
- Posts: 2287
- Joined: Mon 02/10/20 8:24 am
- Location: Belgium
Re: 5E3 and 18 watt classic: anyone has both?
I asked this all because my fellow guitarplayer/singer in the band wants me to build a carryable amp for him. But he's a fender guy and plays a BF twin reverb. I think an 18 watt will be too tight for him. But I can try to convert him to play 18 watters toozaphod_phil wrote: ↑Sat 06/20/20 1:16 pmDid you measure the difference in B+ voltage between the 5Y3 And GZ34. I expect it will have been higher, with the GZ34/5AR4, leading to later breakup. Why did you decide to use octal rectifiers, instead of the standard EZ81?
I feel sorry you chose to use NFB, as that deadens the amp's chime and harmonic richness.
An 18W TMB has the real deal 18W vibe, as long use you don't go spoiling it with stuff like NFB and fixed bias.
Maybe I should borrow him my modern classic for a while... and let's see how that turns out. But like me he needs reverb too. I am about to build that lamington stand alone reverb..so who knows
Me, I just fell madly in love with my TMB tremolo... the last few rehearshals I played without OD pedals and did not miss them ever
Thanx again JMPGuitars !!!!
1 x
"THIS should be played at high volume..preferably in a residential area"
- zaphod_phil
- Builder, Admin
- Posts: 15208
- Joined: Wed 03/19/03 2:00 am
- Location: YYZ
Re: 5E3 and 18 watt classic: anyone has both?
A BF Twin, with its NFB and fixed bias is way tighter than an 18W. So I don't really understand the problem here. 18W amps have a pretty loose, vintage feel.Bieworm wrote: ↑Sat 06/20/20 2:05 pmI asked this all because my fellow guitarplayer/singer in the band wants me to build a carryable amp for him. But he's a fender guy and plays a BF twin reverb. I think an 18 watt will be too tight for him. But I can try to convert him to play 18 watters toozaphod_phil wrote: ↑Sat 06/20/20 1:16 pmDid you measure the difference in B+ voltage between the 5Y3 And GZ34. I expect it will have been higher, with the GZ34/5AR4, leading to later breakup. Why did you decide to use octal rectifiers, instead of the standard EZ81?
I feel sorry you chose to use NFB, as that deadens the amp's chime and harmonic richness.
An 18W TMB has the real deal 18W vibe, as long use you don't go spoiling it with stuff like NFB and fixed bias.
2 x
Nature abhors a clean tube amp
- Bieworm
- Verbose Moderator
- Posts: 2287
- Joined: Mon 02/10/20 8:24 am
- Location: Belgium
Re: 5E3 and 18 watt classic: anyone has both?
I am talking about the huge difference in sound and feel. I was a tweed/brownface player before I build the 18watts. So my tone was kinda,sorta in that ballpark already...zaphod_phil wrote: ↑Sat 06/20/20 6:59 pmA BF Twin, with its NFB and fixed bias is way tighter than an 18W. So I don't really understand the problem here. 18W amps have a pretty loose, vintage feel.Bieworm wrote: ↑Sat 06/20/20 2:05 pmI asked this all because my fellow guitarplayer/singer in the band wants me to build a carryable amp for him. But he's a fender guy and plays a BF twin reverb. I think an 18 watt will be too tight for him. But I can try to convert him to play 18 watters toozaphod_phil wrote: ↑Sat 06/20/20 1:16 pmDid you measure the difference in B+ voltage between the 5Y3 And GZ34. I expect it will have been higher, with the GZ34/5AR4, leading to later breakup. Why did you decide to use octal rectifiers, instead of the standard EZ81?
I feel sorry you chose to use NFB, as that deadens the amp's chime and harmonic richness.
An 18W TMB has the real deal 18W vibe, as long use you don't go spoiling it with stuff like NFB and fixed bias.
I have owned various twins , but I always find them very disapointing. I never understood why one has 85 or 100 watts and still gets lost in the mix...
0 x
"THIS should be played at high volume..preferably in a residential area"
-
- Unrated
- Posts: 8
- Joined: Sat 04/18/20 10:53 am
Re: 5E3 and 18 watt classic: anyone has both?
I'm sure I will have voltage differences when I change the rectifier in the 5E3! Having the NFB, and "fixed" options on switches allows some options.
I have the 18watt circuit board mostly populated, and plan to stay with the TMB circuit. My chassis, and PT were bought when VHT was liquidating, so I will probably use the GZ34 as there is no 6V rectifier winding.
I have the 18watt circuit board mostly populated, and plan to stay with the TMB circuit. My chassis, and PT were bought when VHT was liquidating, so I will probably use the GZ34 as there is no 6V rectifier winding.
0 x
- zaphod_phil
- Builder, Admin
- Posts: 15208
- Joined: Wed 03/19/03 2:00 am
- Location: YYZ
Re: 5E3 and 18 watt classic: anyone has both?
The GZ34 will tend to make the amp stiffer and with more clean headroom than a regular 18W, unless you add a sag resistor. If you prefer more of a vintage feel, a 5Y3 will probably suit you better, while also running off a 5V heater, like a GZ34.
0 x
Nature abhors a clean tube amp
-
- Frequent poster
- Posts: 914
- Joined: Mon 12/10/07 2:00 am
- Location: Melb, Aust
- Contact:
Re: 5E3 and 18 watt classic: anyone has both?
The 5E3 I had for a while was a new build that I was fixing up for someone else. It didn't seem to get the "breakup the 5E3 is known for" either. Had a couple of things that needed changing but the biggest one was to put in a NOS 5Y3. Don't get me wrong either - I almost always use new production valves in my builds, unless it's using the Russki valves I've bought a bit of a collection of. I'm far from a NOS snob. But I read that the new production 5Y3 rectos have less voltage drop and a different curve than the original datasheets. We put a NOS 5Y3 in and it went from sounding blah to totally nailing the 5E3 tone.
3 x
-
- Superior Amp Tech
- Posts: 748
- Joined: Fri 01/08/10 2:00 am
- Location: Scotland
Re: 5E3 and 18 watt classic: anyone has both?
Thanks for that nudge Kato. A couple of weeks ago I found an old rectifier 5Y3 in the cupboard stuck it in the 5E3 and forgot. I was playing the amp a few days ago and thought it sounded rounded and lovely. Your post reminded me about the old rectifier. It may be the reason it sounds different so I will have to investigate.
Dd
Dd
0 x
-
- Unrated
- Posts: 8
- Joined: Sat 04/18/20 10:53 am
Re: 5E3 and 18 watt classic: anyone has both?
Thanks for that!zaphod_phil wrote: ↑Mon 06/22/20 6:57 pmThe GZ34 will tend to make the amp stiffer and with more clean headroom than a regular 18W, unless you add a sag resistor. If you prefer more of a vintage feel, a 5Y3 will probably suit you better, while also running off a 5V heater, like a GZ34.
1 x